The Raid on Deerfield was a French and Indian attack that took place in Deerfield, Massachusetts in 1704 during Queen Anne’s War.
The attack was one of the deadliest during the war and occurred on February 29, 1704, when a force of 50 Frenchman and 200 native warriors attacked the town, killing 48 villagers and taking 112 prisoners.
It wasn’t the first Indian attack on Deerfield though, as the settlement had been attacked previously in 1675, during King Philip’s War, and again in 1694, during King William’s War, and would later be attacked a total of three times in 18th century.
Why Did the French & Indians Attack
The French and their Indian allies had been attacking British settlements in New England throughout Queen Anne’s War as England and France fought to gain control of North America.
a series of successful raids in Maine, the French began to focus on
the Connecticut Valley in 1703.
a British settlement, Deerfield was vulnerable to attack. It was a
small frontier town, the most northwest of all the settlements in
Massachusetts, and was home to only about 300 settlers.
town had a “stockade” (a fortified area in the
center of the village inside a high palisade fence) but only
had about 20 militiamen guarding it.
In May of 1703, Massachusetts governor, Joseph Dudley, received reports from the New York governor, Viscount Cornbury, of a war party of 100 French and Indians headed for Deerfield. Dudley reacted by sending 20 militiamen men from western Massachusetts to Deerfield to protect it.
in July, six months before the raid, Dudley received another report
from some friendly natives of 150 armed natives and a few French
troops gathering near Montreal with plans to divide into three
companies and head towards Maine and the English settlements in
immediately wrote to Connecticut governor Fitz-John Winthrop and
Colonel Samuel Partridge, senior militia officer for western
Massachusetts, to warn them.
the same time, Partridge also received a report of French and Indian
troops from Quebec heading towards New England, according to a letter
Partridge sent to Winthrop:
“I have lately read instructions from his Excellency Joseph Dudley Esqre or Governor of a particular accompt he hath recd of a company of Indians & French that are come out of Quebec & divide themselves to come on Connecticut Merrimack Rivers & the eastern points this night also by an Indian post from Albany I recd from the gentlemen there that on ye 6th Inst three Mohawks came from Canada in 9 days who say that 300 of Indians with some French are come out from Quebec in order to come upon New England, the Indian that brought the letter says he spake with said Mohawks & they told him they had been come out a month so that if these things be true as we have little grounds to question it we having testimony both from east and west agreeing.”
reading the warnings, the Deerfield colonists immediately prepared
for an attack, according to Patridge’s letter:
“…as also the incapacity we are in to defend ourselves, & being now surprised and in daily & hourly fear of the enemies approach especially at Deerfield it being also the likeliest season in all the year for such an enemy to molest us. Our governor together with ye aforesaid instructions appoints us in safe of hazard apparent to apply ourselves to your excellency for relief of men & although we have not yet seen ye enemy in or border yet there being usually little or no time betwixt the discovery of the enemy & their striking their blow that we now upon ye aforesaid have thought it or duty to lay this matter before you with the fears of hazard that we are under propose that you’d please to send up immediately upon ye receipt of these, 50 or 60 men well fixed whom when here such directions & instructions as god shall guide them & us to we hope may of his blessing be beneficial for or relief & disappointment of something of the mischievous intent of or bloody enemies.”
In response to the
letter, Winthrop sent 50 soldiers to guard Deerfield in early August.
The soldiers patrolled the Deerfield area for two days and, after
finding no signs of an imminent attack or of any French or natives
nearby, they were sent home to Connecticut.
Two months later,
on October 8, natives ambushed two Deerfield men, Zebediah Williams
and John Nims, as they were watching over their animals in a nearby
pasture outside of the stockade. Both men were captured and taken to
Canada. In response to the attack, 16 additional soldiers were sent
In early December,
after no further threats or signs of attack, the soldiers from
Connecticut and Massachusetts were withdrawn from Deerfield
and sent home.
Then, in late
January and again in mid-February, Patridge and Dudley received more
reports and warnings of planned French and Indian attacks in the area
but, since the information contained no specific threats or intel,
they offered no additional assistance to Deerfield.
It wasn’t until
Partridge received reports sometime in February of Pennacook Indians
near the New England seacoast area raiding the towns of Berwick,
Maine, Haverhill, Massachusetts and Exeter, New Hampshire that he
finally sent some additional soldiers to Deerfield, the last of which
arrived on February 25.
The threat grew more serious when the Pennacook raiding party, which included about 30 or 40 warriors led by their sachem Wattanummon, joined the French and Indian war party from Canada, led by French commander Jean-Baptiste Hertel De Rouville, about 110 miles north of Deerfield in Cowass as they headed south towards Deerfield.
Then, a few days
before the raid, a strange occurrence took place when some of the
Deerfield settlers reported hearing trampling noises around the
settlement but could not see anyone there, which many of the
villagers saw as a bad omen, according to Herbert Milton Sylvester in
his book Indian Wars of New England:
“The historian, in writing of this Deerfield massacre, refers to a happening of supernatural interest, which for two or three evenings previous to the attack of the Indians became a topic of curious questioning among the Deerfield people. The Reverend Solomon Stoddard alludes to it in these words: ‘The people of Deerfield were strangely amazed by a trampling noise around the fort, as if it were besieged by the Indians.’ There were old men in Deerfield who were led by this evidence to recall similar omens preceding the attack of Philip [during King Philip’s War], ‘when from the clear sky came the sound of horse troops, the roar of artillery, the rattle of small arms and the beating of drums to the charge’” (Sylvester 53).
It is not known
what the strange sounds were, but when the attack happened a few days
later, the villagers later looked back on it as a supernatural
warning of what was to come.
What Happened During the Raid?
On the night of February 28, 1704, a group of 50 Frenchman and 200 native warriors approached the settlement, leaving their supplies in a nearby meadow about 25 to 30 miles north of the area. They established a cold camp about 2 miles from Deerfield where they observed the villagers from a distance.
to Evan Haefeli and Kevin Sweeney in their book Captors and Captives,
this raiding party was one of the largest that had ever been used in
any of the French and Indian Wars and was a serious threat:
“De Rouville’s raiding party was almost five times larger than the raid that his father had led against Salmon Falls, New Hampshire, in winter 1690, and it was more than twice the size of the force of French and Indians that had been sent from Quebec to attack Casco, Maine, in spring 1690. It was larger than the force that had attacked Schenectady in February 1690, though it was easier to move large bodies of men against targets along the New York frontier than against New England. In the 1680s and 1690s, the French had on occasion sent large expeditions than these against the Iroquois League. Mounting expeditions of this size against New England was something new.” (Haefeli and Sweeney 101.)
the villagers had been warned of the pending attack, they all retired
to the stockade area of the village that night while a guard stood
Then, sometime around 4 am, the guard fell asleep and the raiders made their move. Making their way across the meadow, they approached the stockade wall and easily scaled it thanks to a large snow drift piled up next to it, according to the article in American Heritage magazine:
“Over the river, on the ice. Across a mile of meadowland, ghostly and white. Past the darkened houses at the north end of the street. Right up to the stockade. The snow has piled hugely here; the drifts make walkways to the top of the fence. A vanguard of some forty men climbs quickly over and drops down on the inside. A gate is opened to admit the rest. The watch awakens, fires a warning shot, cries, ‘Arm!’ Too late. The attackers separate into smaller parties and ‘immediately set upon breaking open doors and windows.’” (American Heritage paragraph 8).
raider’s plan was to be stationed outside of each house and also at
each gate when the attack began in order to trap the villagers but
this plan failed when the warning shot was fired and the villagers
were alerted to their presence.
a result, the raiders were not in place when the fighting began and
they did not reach the south gate in time to cut off that escape
the fighting commenced, the villagers immediately tried to find ways
to escape their houses by jumping out of windows or off of roofs and
several managed to escape the stockade altogether through the south
of the first houses attacked was that of Reverend John Williams and
his family, according to Williams in a book he later wrote about the
experience, called The Redeemed Captive Returning to Zion:
“On Tuesday, the 29th of February, 1703–4, not long before break of day, the enemy came in like a flood upon us; our watch being unfaithful;—an evil, the awful effects of which, in the surprisal of our fort, should bespeak all watchmen to avoid, as they would not bring the charge of blood upon themselves. They came to my house in the beginning of the onset, and by their violent endeavors to break open doors and windows, with axes and hatchets, awaked me out of sleep; on which I leaped out of bed, and, running towards the door, perceived the enemy making their entrance into the house. I called to awaken two soldiers in the chamber, and returning toward my bedside for my arms, the enemy immediately broke into the room, I judge to the number of twenty, with painted faces, and hideous acclamations.” (Williams 10-11).
goes on to explain that the raiders murdered two of his children in
front of him before eventually marching him and his wife and their
remaining children out of the house:
“About sun an hour high, we were all carried out of the house, for a march, and saw many of the houses of my neighbors in flames, perceiving the whole fort, one house excepted, to be taken. Who can tell what sorrows pierced our souls, when we saw ourselves carried away from God’s sanctuary, to go into a strange land, exposed to so many trials; the journey being at least three hundred miles we were to travel; the snow up to the knees, and we never inured to such hardships and fatigues; the place we were to be carried to, a Popish country. Upon my parting from the town, they fired my house and barn. We were carried over the river, to the foot of the mountain, about a mile from my house, where we found a great number of our Christian neighbors, men, women, and children, to the number of an hundred, nineteen of which were afterward murdered by the way, and two starved to death, near Cowass, in a time of great scarcity or famine the savages underwent there” (Williams 12-13).
Another house that was attacked was
that of Ensign John Sheldon. Fully
aware of the threat of Indian raids on the town, Sheldon had the
foresight to reinforce the door, which made it nearly impossible to
break down. The raiders hacked at the door with their tomahawks and
hatchets but only managed to chop a small hole in the door in which
they then inserted their rifle and fatally shot Mrs. Sheldon.
Sheldon was not home at the time of the attack but his son, John and
daughter-in-law Hannah were upstairs and attempted to escape by
jumping out the window. Both landed in the snow below the window but
Hannah sprained her ankle in the fall and was captured, although John
got away and made it to Hadley, Mass where he raised the alarm.
Only one house within the stockade managed to hold out against the raiders, the house of the militia leader, Sgt. Benoni Stebbins, which was attacked late in the raid.
Although Stebbins himself was killed in
the fight, seven men and a few women successfully defended the home
from the attackers, according to an account of the raid in a letter
by Samuel Patridge:
“One house, viz. Benoni Stebbins’s, they attacked later than some others. That those in it were well awakened, being 7 men, besides women and children, who stood stoutly to their arms, firing upon the enemy, and the enemy [coming] upon them, causing several of the enemy to fall, of which was one Frenchman, a gentleman to [all] appearance. The enemy gave back, they strove to fire the house, [but] our men killed 3 or 4 Indians in their attempt. The enemy being numerous about the house, poured much shot upon the house; [but] the walls being filled up with brick, the force of the shot was repelled. Yet they killed said Stebbins, and wounded one man and one woman, of which the survivors made no discovery of the assailants, but with more than ordinary courage kept firing, having powder and ball sufficient in said house. The enemy betook themselves to the next house and the meeting house, both of which but 8 rods [i.e. 44 yards] distant.” (Captive Histories 65.)
Many of the villagers managed to hide from the raiders in the basement of their houses but later died when the raiders set the houses on fire, according to Samuel Adams Drake in his book The Border Wars of New England:
“All the rest [of the houses] were set on fire, to burn along with the ghastly evidences of the morning’s work. Death, in its most terrible form, thus overtook many who, to escape the tomahawk, had hid themselves in their cellars, only to be stifled beneath the ruins of their burning dwellings. When all was over, forty-seven of the unresisting inhabitants lay dead in or around their own homes. A hundred and twelve more, half dead with cold and fright, were crowded into the Sheldon house, spared for the time being for their reception” (Drake 180.)
Around 9 or 10 am, some of the raiders
began to leave the stockade with their captives and head north.
Around the same time, a group of about 30 to 40 militiamen from
Hatfield and Hadley arrived, after spotting the smoke and flames on
the horizon, and began pursuing the raiders.
The militiamen and raiders skirmished in a meadow just north of Deerfield and nine militiamen were killed and several were wounded when they later ran into an ambush set by the raiders. The surviving militiamen then retreated back to Deerfield.
The next day, an additional 250
militiamen met at Deerfield but determined it wasn’t feasible to
chase the raiders and rescue the captives.
Captivity and March to Canada:
The villagers who were captured were
forced to march the 300-mile-long journey to Canada in the deep snow
in the dead of winter. Those who could not keep up were killed.
Chances of survival seemed to depend on
the captive’s gender and age since infants and young children fared
the worst and more adult men survived than adult women, especially
pregnant women and those with young children.
In the first few days of the journey, several of the captives escaped but after De Rouville instructed Reverend Williams to inform the other captives that recaptured escapees would be tortured, there were no other escape attempts.
Of the more than 100 villagers who were captured, only 89 survived the journey to Canada.
After reaching Canada, the Indians sold
many of the captives to the French, who ransomed about 60 of them
back to the English over a three-year period.
Many of the younger captives assimilated and were adopted into the Indian tribes or French Canadian society. In fact, 36 Deerfield captives, mostly children and teenagers at the time of the raid, remained in Canada permanently, many of them marrying into French or Indian families.
Fates of the
on march to Canada: 21
by 1707: 47
by 1714: 8
with French: 19
with Natives: 7
Who Were the Victims of the Raid?
Alexander, age 45, killed in the meadow fight
(Weld) Alexander, age 37, captured and later returned to Deerfield
Alexander, age 23, captured but escaped the first night
Alexander, age 2, captured and killed en route to Canada
Allen, age 12, captured, remained in Canada where, in 1710, she
married and went by Marie Madeleine
Allis, age 22, captured, returned in 1710
Allis (Of Hatfield), age 25, killed in the meadow fight
Thomas Baker (soldier), age 22, captured, escaped in 1705
(Barnard) Beaman, age 58, captured and later returned
Beaman, age 59, captured and later returned
(Buell) Belding, age 55, captured and killed en route to Canada
Boltwood (of Hadley), age 21, killed in the meadow fight
Boltwood (of Hadley), age 56, killed in the meadow fight
Boltwood (of Hadley), age 17, captured, died in 1714 returning from
Brigdman (soldier), age 29, captured but escaped in the meadows the
(Williams) Brooks, age 31, captured and miscarried en route to Canada
and was killed
Brooks, age 7, captured, never returned
Brooks, age 40, captured and ransomed in 1707
Brooks, age 6, captured, never returned
Brown, age 26, captured and returned
Burt, age 24, captured and ransomed in 1706
(Belden) Burt, age 22, captured and ransomed in 1706
Burt, age 22, captured and ransomed in 1706
Caitlin, age 61, killed in the village
Caitlin, age 17, captured and ransomed in 1706
Caitlin, age 42, killed in the village
Caitlin, age 23, killed in the meadow fight
Caitlin, age 20, captured and ransomed in 1707
Carter, age 7, captured and ransomed in 1707 for 24 pounds
(Weller) Carter, age 30, captured and killed en route to Canada
Carter, age 3, captured and killed en route to Canada
Carter, age 9, captured but remained in Canada as Jean Chartier
Carter, age 7 months, killed en route to Canada
Carter, age 10, captured and remained in Canada, married an Indian
Carter, age 12, captured and died in Canada in 1714
Carter, age 5, killed in the village
(Caitlin) Corse, age 34, captured and killed en route to Canada
Corse, age 8, captured and remained in Canada as Marie Élisabeth
Crowfoot (soldier), age unknown, captured
(Stebbins) de Noyen, age 26, captured and remained in Canada with
de Noyen, age 27, captured and remained in Canada
Dickinson (of Hadley), age 48, captured
Eastman (student), age 21, captured and redeemed in 1707
Field, age 4, captured and ransomed
(Bennett) Field, age 28, captured and ransomed
Field, age 7, captured and remained in Canada where she later married
Field, age 2, killed in village
Foote (of Hatfield), age 27, killed in the meadow fight
(Daniels) Frary, age 62, captured and killed en route to Canada
Frary, age 72, killed in the village
French, age 7, captured and remained in Canada, lived with Indians
French, age 12, captured an remained in Canada as Marie Francoise
French, age 1 month, killed in the village
French, age 9, captured and remained in Canada where she married a
French man and went by Marguerite
(Caitlin) French, age 40, captured and killed en route to Canada
French, age 18, captured and ransomed in 1706
French, age 47, captured and ransomed in 1706
French, age 17, captured and ransomed in 1706
Harris, age 11, captured and remained in Canada where she later
Hastings, age 20, captured and never returned
(Allis) Hawks, age 57, killed in the village
Hawks, age 7, killed en route to Canada
Hawks, age 31, killed in the village
Hawks, age 8, killed in the village
Hawks, age 5, killed in the village
(Smead) Hawks, age 27, killed in the village
Hawks, age 3, killed in the village
Hickson/Hix, age 19, killed en route to Canada
Hinsdale, age 31, captured and ransomed in 1706
(Rider) Hinsdale, age 24, captured and ransomed in 1706
Hinsdale, age 1, killed in the village
(Cooke) (Pomeroy) Hoyt, age 44, captured and later returned
Hoyt, age 3, captured and killed en route to Canada
Hoyt Sr, age 52, captured and killed en route to Canada
Hoyt Jr., age 28, killed in the meadow fight
Hoyt, age 9, captured and never returned
Hoyt, age 16, captured and ransomed in 1707
Hoyt, age 18, captured and returned in 1714
Hull, age 16, captured and later returned
Hurst, age 2, captured and killed en route to Canada
Hurst, age 5, captured and remained in Canada as Antoine Nicolas
Hurst, age 16, captured and remained in Canada as Marie Elizabeth
Hurst, age 8, captured and later returned
(Jeffreys) Hurst, age unknown, captured and later returned
Hurst, age 18, captured and later returned
Hurst, age 12, captured and remained in Canada
Ingersol, age 29, killed in the village
Ingram (of Hadley), age unknown, killed in the meadow fight
Kellogg, age 11, captured and remained in Canada where she married an
Kellogg, age 5, killed in the village
Kellogg, age 13, captured and released in 1714
Kellogg, age 46, captured and ransomed in 1706
Kellogg, age 18, captured and escaped in 1705
Kellogg, age 9, captured and remained in Canada with the Indians
Marsh (of Hatfield), age 32, captured
Mattoon, age 24, captured and killed en route to Canada
(Nims) Mattoon, age 24, killed in the village
Girl Mattoon, killed in the village
Mattoon, age 17, captured and later returned
Nims, age 4, captured and remained in Canada as Marie Elizabeth
Nims, age 18, captured and returned in 1714
Nims, age 22, killed in the village
Nims, age 5, killed in the village
Nims, age 5, killed in the village
(Smead) Nims, age 36, killed en route to Canada
Nims, age 7, killed in the village
Petty, age 31, captured and escaped in 1705
(Edwards) Petty, age 25, captured and ransomed in 1706
Pomeroy, age unknown, captured and killed en route to Canada
Pomeroy, age 29, captured and returned somtime before 1708
Pomeroy, age 10, captured and later returned
Price, age 18, captured and returned about 1714
(Webb) Price, age 53, captured and killed en route to Canada
Richards, age 9, captured and never returned
Rising (Visiting), age 10, captured and remained in Canada as Ignace
Roote, age 15, captured and killed in the village
Sheldon, age 13, captured later returned
(Stebbins) Sheldon, age 40, killed in the village
(Chapin) Sheldon, age 24, captured and ransomed in 1706
Sheldon, age 17, captured and ransomed in 1706
Sheldon, age 3, killed in the village
Sheldon, age 7, captured and ransomed in 1706
Sheldon, age 27, killed in the village
(Lawrence) Smead, age 66, killed in the village
(Price) Smead, age 23, killed in the village
Smead, age 4, killed in the village
Smead, age 3, killed in the village
Smith, age unknown, killed in the village
Stebbins, age 49, killed in the Village
(Alexander) Stebbins, age 44, captured and returned six days later
Stebbins, age 9, captured and remained in Canada as Jacques Charles
Stebbins, age 57, captured and returned six days later
Stebbins Jr., age 20, captured and returned six days later
Stebbins, age 4, captured and remained in Canada as Joseph Stebenne
Stebbins, age 16, captured and returned in 1723
Stebbins, age 12, captured and remained as Louise Therese
Stevens (Indian), age 25, killed in the village
(Price) Stevens, age 21, captured and remained in Canada where she
later married and went by Marie Elizabeth
Waite (of Hatfield), age 64, killed in the meadow fight
Warner, age 29, captured and returned
Warner, age 5, captured and returned
(Smead) Warner, age 25, captured and killed en route to Canada
Warner, age 3, captured and remained in Canada
Warner (of Hadley), age 23, killed in the meadow fight
Wells, age 29, killed in the village
Williams, age 13, captured and ransomed in 1706
(Mather) Williams, age 40, killed en route to Canada
Williams, age 8, captured and remained in Canada where she married an
Williams, age 1 month, killed in the village
Williams, age 1, killed in the village
Williams, age 40, captured and ransomed in 1706
Williams, age 15, captured and ransomed in 1706
Williams, age 9, captured and ransomed in 1706
Williams, age 4, captured and ransomed in 1706
(Williams servant), age unknown, killed en route to Canada
(Williams servant), age unknown, killed in the village
Weston, age unknown, captured
Wright (Soldier), age 27, captured and returned about 1707
Where Are the Deerfield Victims Buried?
According to local legend, the survivors of the raid buried the 48 victims in a mass grave in the corner of the town cemetery.
1901, a monument was placed on the grave, which reads “The Dead of
1704” on one side and “The grave of 48 men women and children,
victims of the French and Indian raid on Deerfield. February 29,
1704” on the opposite side.
cemetery, known as Old Albany Cemetery, still exists and is located
at the end of Albany Road.
Sylvester, Herbert Milton. Indians Wars of New England, Vol. III, 1910.
Williams, John. The Redeemed Captive Returning to Zion. Hopkins, Bridgman and Company, 1853.
Haefeli, Evan and Kevin Sweeney. Captors and Captives: The 1704 French and Indian Raid on Deerfield. University of Massachusetts Press, 2003.
Haefeli, Evan and Kevin Sweeney. Captive Histories: English, French and Native Narratives of the 1704 Deerfield Raid. University of Massachusetts Press, 2006.
Drake, Samuel Adams. The Border Wars of New England. Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1897.
“Sheldon House Door.” Raid on Deerfield: The Many Stories of 1704, 1704.deerfield.history.museum/popups/artifacts.do?shortName=door&anchorName=
“The People – Brief Bios.” Raid on Deerfield: The Many Stories of 1704, 1704.deerfield.history.museum/people/short_bios.jsp
“Deerfield Captives of 1704.” Debbie’s Pages, www.babcock-acres.com/Misceallaneous/deerfield_captives_of_1704.htm
“Eunice Williams, The Unredeemed Captive.” New England Historical Society, www.newenglandhistoricalsociety.com/eunice-williams-unredeemed-captive/
“The Mischief at Deerfield.” Massachusetts Historical Society, Jan. 2004, www.masshist.org/object-of-the-month/objects/the-mischief-at-deerfield-2004-01-01
“Deerfield Massacre Mass Grave.” Atlas Obsura, www.atlasobscura.com/places/deerfield-massacre-mass-grave
Schweitzer, Sarah. “Language Change: Objections to some blunt landmarks from 1704 Indian raid lead to editing.” Boston Globe, 20 June, 2004, archive.boston.com/news/local/massachusetts/articles/2004/06/20/a_language_change?pg=full
“Deerfield – Sheldon Talks About Monuments.” Memorial Hall Museum Online, www.memorialhall.mass.edu/collection/itempage.jsp?itemid=16317
Grant, Ross. “Historic Deerfield Buys 1703 Letter That Predicts Attack.” Memorial Hall Museum Online, www.memorialhall.mass.edu/classroom/curriculum_12th/unit1/lesson7/1703_letter.html
“Warning Letter from Samuel Partridge.” Raid on Deerfield: The Many Stories of 1704, 1704.deerfield.history.museum/popups/artifacts.do?shortName=partridge
“The Mischief at Deerfield.” Massachusetts Historical Society, www.masshist.org/object-of-the-month/objects/the-mischief-at-deerfield-2004-01-01
Moonan, Wendy. “Antiques; A Historic Raid, From All Sides.” New York Times, 27 Feb. 2004, www.nytimes.com/2004/02/27/arts/antiques-a-historic-raid-from-all-sides.html
“1704 Raid on Deerfield and Captivity.” Longmeadow Historical Society, www.longmeadowhistoricalsociety.org/stephenwilliams/Deerfield-Raid.html
Demos, John. “The Deerfield Massacre.” American Heritage, February/March 1993, Volume 44, Issue 1, www.americanheritage.com/deerfield-massacre